Catholic Marriage

17/9/06

My stepdaughter has recently married in a Anglican high church now she has been told she can no longer take communion in her own catholic church - ( why) it is not wrong we are of the same faith. Can someone help on this? 
Brother Anthony Fanthom 
St Luke,  Wellingborough


REPLIES 

Peter Hooper - 18/9/06 

I assume you mean Roman Catholic. If so yes we are all Christians, but the Roman Church does not let others receive communion. Anglican and Roman are not the same faith.

Peter Hooper 

Quintin Butcher - 18/9/06

I understand that as your stepdaughter has married outside of the Roman catholic church ie:Anglican. she has reneged on her Roman catholic faith. She should have married in a Roman church. therefore she has been excomunicated.
Quintin Butcher 
Holy Grail PG10

Alan Sabey - 18/9/06

Perhaps the Roman Catholics feel she has deserted them by marrying in an Anglican church. We all know that the Roman church does not give Holy Communion to anyone who is not Roman Catholic. 
Alan Sabey
Chapter of the Holy Rood,
Norwood, Middlesex

David Froud - 19/9/06

It would seem to depend on WHO YOU ARE. Tony Blair has received communion at a number of RC church in this company AND in the Vatican. Although the CofE is in DIALOGUE with both the ROMAN and Orthodox churches, it is NOT in COMMUNION therefore Anglicans cannot expect to receive the sacrament from these Churches. The question of the step-daughter not being admitted to communion and the other sacraments is a matter that should be discussed with THEIR hierachy.

We should not say whether they are or are not excommunicated. That is a question between them and God. One may only wish to consider the number of faithfull who under these terms are out of communion because of the rules
about methods of contraception.

They seem to have few qualms about going to Mass and taking communion. My personal advice would be to pray about the matter as seek spiritual counsel.

David Froud
Councillor PG 10 

Lee Clark - 19/9/06

May I recommend the following website: http://www.interchurchfamilies.org.uk/

Lee Clark

Holy Trinity Barkingside

To reply click here

Return to Forum Main Page